BIRCH RATINGS

AccuRatings

 

BIRCH RATINGS

Throughout the 1980s and into the early 90s, the Birch Research Corporation was the primary competitor to Arbitron in the radio ratings business.  The methodology of the two services was what set them apart.  While Arbitron relies on people to recall what they have listened over a seven-day period in a written diary, Birch utilized phone interviews to gather its data.  Respondents were asked to recall their radio listening over the prior twenty-four hours.  Because the phone methodology often yielded higher listening estimates for stations that targeted younger listeners, Birch became the favored ratings service in the eyes of top 40 and rock stations.  Birch also utilized its phone interviews to gather detailed qualitative information through a service it called Scarborough.  This allowed stations to obtain a clearer picture of the audience that was listening.  After Birch's demise, the Scarborough division was purchased by Arbitron, which still produces annual qualitative reports under that name.  What follows is the Birch data I have managed to gather thus far, please let me know if you can help fill in any of the holes!

12+  Birch Ratings for Spring 1987    
Call Letters Frequency Format   Sp 1987
KKDA-FM 104.5 Urban   10.1
KEGL 97.1 Top 40   9.4
KVIL-A/F 1150/103.7 Adult Contemporary   8.2
KPLX 99.5 Country   8.0
KRLD 1080 News/Talk   6.0
WBAP 820 Country   5.4
KHYI 94.9 Top 40   5.1
KSCS 96.3 Country   4.8
KTXQ 102.1 Rock   4.5
KZEW 97.9 Rock   4.3
         
12+  Birch Ratings for Spring 1988    
Call Letters Frequency Format   Sp 1988
KKDA-FM 104.5 Urban   10.8
KPLX 99.5 Country   9.2
KVIL-A/F 1150/103.7 Adult Contemporary   7.8
KHYI 94.9 Top 40   7.1
KEGL 97.1 Top 40   6.4
KTXQ 102.1 Rock   5.8
WBAP 820 Country   4.4
KZEW 97.9 Rock   4.2
KSCS 96.3 Country   3.7
KRLD 1080 News/Talk   3.5
         
12+  Birch Ratings for Spring 1990    
Call Letters Frequency Format   Sp 1990
KSCS 96.3 Country   9.3
KKDA-FM 104.5 Urban   7.0
KPLX 99.5 Country   6.9
KVIL-A/F 1150/103.7 Adult Contemporary   6.5
KJMZ 100.3 Urban   6.0
KTXQ 102.1 Rock   5.9
KEGL 97.1 Top 40   5.1
KHYI 94.9 Top 40   5.0
KOAI 106.1 Smooth Jazz   3.9
WBAP 820 Full Service   3.9
         
12+  Birch Ratings for Winter 1991    
Call Letters Frequency Format   Wi 1991
KSCS 96.3 Country   10.9
KKDA-FM 104.5 Urban   7.3
KPLX 99.5 Country   6.9
KVIL-A/F 1150/103.7 Adult Contemporary   6.2
KRLD 1080 News/Talk   5.3
KTXQ 102.1 Rock   5.0
KJMZ 100.3 Urban   4.9
WBAP 820 News/Talk   4.6
KEGL 97.1 Top 40   4.4
KHYI 94.9 Top 40   3.8
         
12+  Birch Ratings for Spring 1991    
Call Letters Frequency Format Wi 1991 Sp 1991
KSCS 96.3 Country 10.9 11.0
KPLX 99.5 Country 6.9 7.2
KKDA-FM 104.5 Urban 7.3 7.0
KTXQ 102.1 Rock 5.0 6.4
KVIL-A/F 1150/103.7 Adult Contemporary 6.2 5.1
KEGL 97.1 Top 40 4.4 4.9
KJMZ 100.3 Urban 4.9 4.9
WBAP 820 Full Service 4.6 4.2
KRLD 1080 News/Talk 5.3 4.0
KHYI 94.9 Top 40 3.8 3.8
         
12+  Birch Ratings for Summer 1991    
Call Letters Frequency Format Sp 1991 Su 1991
KSCS 96.3 Country 11.0 11.0
KTXQ 102.1 Rock 6.4 7.7
KJMZ 100.3 Urban 4.9 6.1
KPLX 99.5 Country 7.2 6.0
KKDA-FM 104.5 Urban 7.0 5.9
WBAP 820 Full Service 4.2 5.4
KEGL 97.1 Top 40 4.9 4.8
KVIL-A/F 1150/103.7 Adult Contemporary 5.1 4.7
KZPS 92.5 Classic Rock 3.0 4.0
KDGE 94.5 Alternative 3.3 3.8
         
12+  Birch Ratings for Fall 1991    
Call Letters Frequency Format Su 1991 Fa 1991
KSCS 96.3 Country 11.0 11.1
KPLX 99.5 Country 6.0 7.7
KJMZ 100.3 Urban 6.1 7.0
KTXQ 102.1 Rock 7.7 6.3
KKDA-FM 104.5 Urban 5.9 5.0
KEGL 97.1 Top 40 4.8 4.6
KVIL-A/F 1150/103.7 Adult Contemporary 4.7 4.1
KOAI 106.1 Smooth Jazz 2.0 4.0
WBAP 820 Full Service 5.4 4.0
KRLD 1080 News/Talk 2.4 3.6

ACCURATINGS

After the demise of the Birch ratings, Strategic Radio Research launched a service designed to fill the void called "AccuRatings".  Like Birch, AccuRatings utilized phone interview methodology, and also provided more detailed demographic information than Arbitron.  Unlike Birch, which queried people's listening habits over the previous day, AccuRatings asked people to name the station they thought of as their "most listened to".  Also unique to AccuRatings was the fact that in their initial surveys, no trending data was listed in their reports.  Instead, respondents were asked what station they listened to most six months ago, this resulting figure was listed as the "Recalled Former Share" or RFS.  This was to give an idea of a station's rise or decline based upon listener's perceptions rather than simply comparing past raw data. 

AccuRatings later abandoned the "RFS" methodology and simply trended their data from survey to survey.   AccuRatings became "AccuTrack" in 1997, and a year later Strategic Radio Research put an end to its market-wide surveys in favor of focusing on research projects for individual radio stations.  What follows is the AccuRatings data I have managed to gather, please let me know if you have any information you may be able to contribute.

12+  AccuRatings for Fall 1993    
Call Letters Frequency Format RFS* Fa 1993
KSCS 96.3 Country 7.8 7.2
KYNG 105.3 Country 6.0 6.9
KHKS 106.1 CHR 4.0 5.8
KJMZ 100.3 Urban 5.9 5.7
KDGE 94.5 Alternative 4.2 5.2
WBAP 820 News/Talk 4.5 4.7
KPLX 99.5 Country 4.8 4.6
KKDA-FM 104.5 Urban 4.1 4.4
KRLD 1080 News/Talk 4.4 4.4
KVIL-A/F 1150/103.7 Adult Contemporary 4.2 4.1
         
12+ AccuRatings for Winter 1994    
Call Letters Frequency Format RFS* Wi 1994
KYNG 105.3 Country 6.4 7.0
KSCS 96.3 Country 7.6 6.6
KHKS 106.1 CHR 5.0 6.0
KJMZ 100.3 Urban 5.4 5.9
KDGE 94.5 Alternative 4.2 5.6
KPLX 99.5 Country 5.1 4.8
WBAP 820 News/Talk 4.5 4.6
KKDA-FM 104.5 Urban 4.3 4.3
KVIL-A/F 1150/103.7 Adult Contemporary 4.0 4.2
KOAI 107.5 Smooth Jazz 3.7 4.0
KEGL 97.1 Rock 3.6 4.0
         
12+ AccuRatings for Summer 1996    
Call Letters Frequency Format Sp 1996 Su 1996
KHKS 106.1 CHR 6.9 7.0
KKDA-FM 104.5 Urban 8.1 6.7
KYNG 105.3 Country 5.1 5.4
KSCS 96.3 Country 6.0 5.0
WBAP 820 News/Talk 4.7 4.9
KDGE 94.5 Alternative 5.7 4.2
KEGL 97.1 Rock 3.5 4.0
KRLD 1080 News 3.4 4.0
KVIL-A/F 1150/103.7 Adult Contemporary 4.3 4.0
KLUV 98.7 Oldies 4.2 3.6
         
12+ AccuRatings for Fall 1996    
Call Letters Frequency Format Su 1996 Fa 1996
KKDA-FM 104.5 Urban 6.7 8.5
KHKS 106.1 CHR 7.0 7.9
KYNG 105.3 Country 5.4 5.8
KSCS 96.3 Country 5.0 5.3
WBAP 820 News/Talk 4.9 4.9
KVIL 1150/103.7 Adult Contemporary 4.0 4.0
KRLD 1080 News 4.0 3.9
KLTY 94.1 Christian AC 3.1 3.7
KLUV 98.7 Oldies 3.6 3.7
KDGE 94.5 Alternative 4.2 3.6
         
12+ AccuRatings for Winter 1997    
Call Letters Frequency Format Fa 1996 Wi 1997
KKDA-FM 104.5 Urban 8.5 9.5
KHKS 106.1 CHR 7.9 7.5
KSCS 96.3 Country 5.3 5.7
KYNG 105.3 Country 5.8 5.3
KRLD 1080 News 3.9 4.9
WBAP 820 News/Talk 4.9 4.9
KVIL 1150/103.7 Adult Contemporary 4.0 4.2
KDGE 94.5 Alternative 3.6 3.9
KLTY 94.1 Christian AC 3.7 3.7
KEGL 97.1 Rock 3.3 3.6
         
12+ AccuRatings for Summer 1997    
Call Letters Frequency Format Sp 1997 Su 1997
KKDA-FM 104.5 Urban   9.5
WBAP 820 News/Talk   6.0
KHKS 106.1 CHR   5.4
KEGL 97.1 Rock   4.7
KZPS 92.5 Classic Rock   4.6
KSCS 96.3 Country   4.5
KRLD 1080 News   4.4
KDGE 94.5 Alternative   4.3
KLUV 98.7 Oldies   4.2
KTCK 1310 Sports   4.0
         
12+ AccuTrack Ratings for Fall 1997    
Call Letters Frequency Format Su 1997 Fa 1997
KKDA-FM 104.5 Urban 9.5 10.5
KHKS 106.1 CHR 5.4 9.1
KSCS 96.3 Country 4.5 5.7
KDGE 94.5 Alternative 4.3 4.5
KVIL 1150/103.7 Adult Contemporary 1.9 4.1
KYNG 105.3 Country 3.5 4.1
KRLD 1080 News 4.4 3.8
KZPS 92.5 Classic Rock 4.6 3.5
KPLX 99.5 Country 2.6 3.3
WBAP 820 News/Talk 6.0 3.3
         
12+ AccuTracks for Winter 1998    
Call Letters Frequency Format Fa 1997 Wi 1998
KKDA-FM 104.5 Urban 10.5 11.0
KHKS 106.1 CHR 9.1 9.9
KSCS 96.3 Country 5.7 4.4
KYNG 105.3 Country 4.1 4.3
WBAP 820 News/Talk 3.3 4.3
KDGE 94.5 Alternative 4.5 3.9
KVIL 1150/103.7 Adult Contemporary 4.1 3.8
KEGL 97.1 Rock 3.1 3.6
KRLD 1080 News 3.8 3.6
KZPS 92.5 Classic Rock 3.5 3.6